Radio Control and Battery Power for Model Railroads
  • Home
  • Radio Control
  • Battery Power
    • Batteries Explained
    • Battery Care
  • Quick Start
    • Getting Started
  • Price List
  • Documents
    • Hints, Comments, Notes
  • Contact Us
  • Neil's Blog

BPS Current Limiting

7/24/2013

 
The S-CAB battery power supply (BPS) provides 12 volt on-board power from a 3.7 volt lithium polymer (LiPo) battery. The design emphasizes safety; for battery, BPS components and the loco in which BPS is installed. The battery charger built into the BPS ensures the battery cannot be over-charged. A protective circuit module (PCM) integrated into the battery assembly protects the battery from over-current and under-voltage conditions. In addition, BPS output includes current limiting to prevent over-load conditions from damaging BPS components.
BPS specifications define a maximum current output of 500 mA, which is adequate for HO, On3, On30 and some S scale locomotives, so long as they are in reasonably good mechanical condition. Designing for higher output would have required a larger circuit board and excluded BPS from many HO applications due to space limitations. So the trade-off between current output and size is a compromise.
Based on operational experience and improved characteristics of both battery and PCM, BPS overload behavior is safe and predictable, as demonstrated in the following graph. Output voltage is constant 12 volts for current output up to 400 mA and drops to about 11 volts at 500 mA. Beyond 500 mA, output voltage drops significantly due to current limiting built into BPS.
Picture
This test used a resistor as the load. A loco motor behaves differently. As voltage drops, the motor just won't produce enough power to move the loco.
Conclusion: I hope this explains why I want to know the loco motor's full load current when supplying a BPS. It's also the reason BPS installation instructions require a bench test of the BPS before installing in a loco. If a loco runs well on the bench with no load, but does not run when loaded, it may be exceeding the BPS 500 mA rating. In this case, it's the loco mechanism that needs to be examined.

Engineering comment: Using a resistive load extends the current range of the test to 1.4 amps. This required a
resistor of less than 3 ohms. As voltage drops, a motor will slow and ultimately stall. With current limiting, the higher the stall current, the lower the voltage. Leaving a loco decoder on full throttle with the loco stalled may be hard on the decoder and/or the motor, but the voltage will be low enough to prevent serious damage. The resistance of a HO scale loco motor is somewhat greater than 3 ohms, which means the stall current will be less than 1.4 amps. Most decoders can survive this condition.

HO Scale GP35 Conversion

7/16/2013

 
Picture
I recently completed this conversion, installing both S-CAB radio control and adding BPS battery power supply. In HO scale, the engine compartment inside width of 3/4" complicates the project and requires a non-standard battery.
The model (photographed here without handrails and other trim) was manufactured by Kato and is quite "friendly" from an assembly perspective.

The motor sits fairly low on the chassis, leaving useful space above the motor for battery and BPS. The dynamic braking hood is removable and I used this to make wiring more accessible. Decoder and radio receiver are mounted using a piece of circuit board attached to the motor bracket. The radio antenna is mounted vertically.
Picture
Since this arrangement requires 7 wires connecting the chassis to roof-mounted components, I added a socket to allow loco body and chassis to be separated. This facilitates testing and simplifies maintenance, should it ever be required.
Picture
Several original Kato items had to be removed to clear space above the motor; a wiring bracket (replaced with the circuit board), a metal weight, incandescent light bulbs and plastic "light-pipes" for head and rear lights.
Picture
Picture
Most of the "light-pipe" was cut off so that only the actual headlight and rear light portions were retained. The end of what was left of the light pipe was polished smooth and LEDs were glued using epoxy cement.

I also added an LED (with 2.2K resistor) in the loco cab and wired it to BPS 12 volt output to indicate battery power on or off.


PictureUsing magnetic wand to turn on battery power
The BPS circuit board includes a magnetic sensor used to turn on battery power.

PictureUsing magnetic wand to turn off battery power
To turn the battery off, I added a second magnetic sensor in front of the cab.


Non-standard battery: Mechanically, this loco is well-engineered and has a Can motor requiring less than 500 mA full load. Because of space limitations, I used a smaller LiPo with 2 cells wired in parallel. This provides 900 mAh storage in a package measuring 2" long, 5/8" wide and 1/2" thick. Since, stiff battery leads were unworkable in the limited space, I substituted very flexible wire, eliminated the battery socket and soldered battery leads directly to the BPS.
Picture
Finally, here's a photo with the dynamic braking hood removed showing the opening I created to improve access to BPS and lighting connections.

    Author

    I'm a retired electrical engineer, but still spending more time on engineering than on my layout. These days, it's mostly about applying radio control and battery power on smaller scale layouts (HO, On3, On30)

    Categories

    All
    Historical
    Installation Notes
    Loco Projects
    Operation

    The photo above is not my layout. It's a great view of Seattle's King Street station by Ross Fotheringham.

    Archives

    February 2019
    October 2018
    September 2017
    August 2016
    April 2016
    January 2015
    November 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013

    S-CAB Conversions:
    S-scale NW2 Switcher
    On30 D&RG 4-4-0
    HO-scale GP9
    HO-scale GP35
    HO brass 4-8-4
    HO Bachmann 2-6-2

    S-scale EMD F-40PH
    HO-scale ALCO DL-109
    On30 Forney
    HO-scale Atlas-Kato GP-7


Proudly powered by Weebly